Let's break down the information provided and explain it point by point:
1. **Perfect Hedge**: When all the characteristics of an existing position match exactly with the futures contract specifications, it creates a perfect hedge. In a perfect hedge, any potential loss on the hedged position will be precisely offset by the gain on the futures position.
2. **Reasons for Imperfect Hedges**: Perfect hedges are not very common due to two major reasons:
a. **Dissimilar Assets**: Often, the asset in the existing position is not the same as the one underlying the futures contract. For example, someone might attempt to hedge a portfolio of corporate bonds using a futures contract on U.S. Treasury bonds. Since these assets may have different price movements, a perfect hedge becomes challenging.
b. **Mismatched Hedging Horizon**: The hedging horizon, which is the time period for which the hedge is intended, may not perfectly match the maturity of the futures contract. If the futures position is closed out before its maturity, the return to the futures position may differ from the return to the cash position.
3. **Basis Risk**: The existence of either (1) dissimilar assets or (2) mismatched hedging horizons leads to what is called basis risk. Basis, in this context, refers to the difference between the spot price of the asset being hedged and the futures price of the hedging instrument (the futures contract).
Basis = Spot price of asset being hedged - Futures price of contract used in the hedge
When the hedged asset and the asset underlying the hedging instrument are the same, the basis will be zero at the maturity of the futures contract.
4. **Efficiency in Cross Hedging**: Sometimes, it may be more efficient to perform a cross hedge, which means hedging a cash position with a hedging instrument that is closely related but different from the cash asset. For example, hedging a position in one type of corn using a futures contract on a different type of corn. Cross hedging can be employed when the assets have similar price movements or are highly correlated.
5. **Alternate Definition of Basis**: While the typical definition of basis is spot price minus futures price, in the context of financial asset futures, it is sometimes defined as futures price minus spot price.
6. **Basis Risk and its Management**: When hedging, a change in basis is unavoidable over the hedge horizon. This change in basis is referred to as basis risk. Basis risk can work either in favor of or against a hedger. To minimize basis risk, hedgers should consider two factors:
a. **Correlation**: Choose a futures contract on an asset that is highly correlated with the spot position being hedged. The higher the correlation, the more effective the hedge is likely to be.
b. **Maturity Matching**: Select a futures contract with a maturity that closely aligns with the hedging horizon. The closer the maturity matches the hedging horizon, the better the hedge will perform.
Let's illustrate basis risk with a simple numerical example:
Suppose a wheat farmer wants to hedge the price risk of their wheat crop, which they plan to harvest and sell in six months. The current spot price of wheat is $300 per bushel. The farmer decides to use wheat futures contracts to hedge their position.
1. The farmer buys one wheat futures contract with a current futures price of $310 per bushel, expiring in six months (matching the hedging horizon).
2. Initially, the basis is calculated as:
Basis = Spot price - Futures price
Basis = $300 - $310 = -$10 per bushel
The negative basis indicates that the futures price is higher than the spot price, which is typical for agricultural commodities due to storage costs and interest.
3. Over the next few months, the spot price of wheat increases to $330 per bushel, while the futures price increases to $340 per bushel.
4. At the end of the hedging horizon (six months), the basis has changed:
Basis = Spot price - Futures price
Basis = $330 - $340 = -$10 per bushel
The basis remained constant at -$10 per bushel, meaning the futures price continued to be $10 higher than the spot price.
5. The farmer sells their wheat crop at the spot price of $330 per bushel, resulting in a gain of $30 per bushel ($330 - $300).
6. However, the futures position incurred a loss because the futures price at maturity was $340 per bushel, while the initial futures price was $310 per bushel. The loss on the futures position is $30 per bushel ($310 - $340).
7. The gain from the cash position ($30) perfectly offset the loss from the futures position ($30), resulting in a perfect hedge despite the basis risk.
In this example, although the basis remained constant, the farmer was still exposed to basis risk, which can arise if the basis changes over the hedging period.
Sure! Here are some multiple-choice questions related to hedging, perfect hedges, basis risk, and hedging strategies, along with their answers:
Question 1:
What is a "perfect hedge" in financial markets?
A) A hedge that perfectly matches the hedging horizon with the maturity of the futures contract.
B) A hedge that eliminates all risks associated with the underlying asset.
C) A hedge where the spot price and futures price of the underlying asset are exactly the same.
D) A hedge that uses multiple futures contracts to minimize basis risk.
Answer: C) A hedge where the spot price and futures price of the underlying asset are exactly the same.
Question 2:
Why are perfect hedges not very common in practice?
A) Investors are not aware of the concept of hedging.
B) The spot price and futures price are never the same for any asset.
C) The hedging horizon is always shorter than the maturity of the futures contract.
D) Assets in the existing position may not perfectly match the underlying asset of the futures contract or the hedging horizon may not match the futures contract's maturity.
Answer: D) Assets in the existing position may not perfectly match the underlying asset of the futures contract, or the hedging horizon may not match the futures contract's maturity.
Question 3:
What is "basis risk" in hedging?
A) The risk that the spot price of the underlying asset will change unexpectedly.
B) The risk that the futures price will be lower than the spot price at the hedge's maturity.
C) The risk that the basis of a hedged position will be zero.
D) The risk that the spot price and futures price will move differently, leading to imperfect hedging.
Answer: D) The risk that the spot price and futures price will move differently, leading to imperfect hedging.
Question 4:
In which situation would a cross hedge be more appropriate than a perfect hedge?
A) When the hedging horizon perfectly matches the futures contract's maturity.
B) When the assets in the existing position are highly correlated with the underlying asset of the futures contract.
C) When the spot price and futures price are the same.
D) When the spot price and futures price are expected to diverge significantly.
Answer: D) When the spot price and futures price are expected to diverge significantly.
Question 5:
How is "basis" calculated in hedging?
A) Spot price plus futures price.
B) Spot price minus futures price.
C) Futures price plus spot price.
D) Futures price minus spot price.
Answer: B) Spot price minus futures price. (Note: The alternate definition mentioned in the professor's note is not considered in this question.)
These questions cover the key concepts related to hedging, basis risk, and hedging strategies. Make sure to review the answers and explanations to deepen your understanding of these topics.
No comments:
Post a Comment